by , on November 28, 2012

Arc Flash and Safety Newsletter banner
In This Issue
Updated 2012 Classes
OSHA Fines
Burn Up the Myth
NFPA 70E Errata 70E-12-1
Arc Test Dates
ASTM D1048-12 Standard Alert
ASTM Tracking Alert
ESW 2013 Registration
Race for the Cure
Electrical Safety News
Train the Trainer Class


Revco ad2
Revco Industries



Youngstown Glove


Milliken Logo


Walls 2012 Ad

Upcoming Classes

 Open Registration:

NFPA 70E 2012 Electrical Safety in the Workplace 


  NFPA 70E-2012 CLASSES 


Louisville, KY

December 3, 2012


Phoenix, AZ

January 22, 2013


Greensboro, NC

February 15, 2013


Seattle, WA

February 18, 2013


Reno, NV

February 26, 2013


Louisville, KY

March 4, 2013


Deerfield, IL

March 5, 2013


Seattle, WA

April 2, 2013


Evansville, IN

April 4, 2013


Knoxville, TN

April 24, 2013


Greensboro, NC

May 10, 2013


Cincinnati, OH

May 13, 2013



June 4, 2013


Reno, NV

August 13, 2013


Evansville, IN

September 12, 2013


Louisville, KY

September 23, 2013


Deerfield, IL

September 24, 2013


Cincinnati, OH

October 14, 2013


Greensboro, NC

October 25, 2013


Billings, MT

October 29, 2013





Seattle, WA

February 19, 2013


Louisville, KY

December 4, 2012


Louisville, KY

March 5, 2013


Louisville, KY

September 24, 2013


Billings, MT

October 30, 2013





Louisville, KY

December 3-6, 2012


Seattle, WA

February 18-21, 2013


Louisville, KY

March 4-7, 2013


Louisville, KY

September 23-26, 2013





Cincinnati, OH

May 14, 2013


Cincinnati, OH

October 14, 2013





Cincinnati, OH

May 14 – May 15, 2013


Cincinnati, OH

Oct 14 – Oct 15, 2013





Click here to view e-Hazard training calendar.





Featured Product
Dickie's Electrician's Belt

Featured Product
NEW ArcSuspender with arc tested clips
Arc Flash Suspender Detail
Arc Flash Suspender
Featured Product

Carhartt Electrician's Belt

2013 IEEE Expo

 IEEE ESW 2010

IEEE IAS 2013 Electrical Safety Workshop

Anatole Hilton Hotel

Dallas, TX

March 11-15, 2013

Our Sponsors


Walls 2012 Ad Walls


Milliken Logo



Youngstown Glove


Revco ad2  
Revco Industries

Updated 2012 Classes
LV Book Cover 
Over 350 trainers have been through the Low Voltage (LV) and High Voltage (HV) Train the Trainer course with e-Hazard, and are qualified to teach using e-Hazard materials.  More trainers use e-Hazard training materials than all our competitors combined. 
Come to an open-registration class or attend our  Train the Trainer course and experience the e-Hazard difference.  Competitors welcome.
 Low Voltage
Low Voltage Refresher
 High Voltage 
High Voltage Refresher
LV & HV Train the Trainer
 Operator’s Class
OSHA 10 Hour
We also schedule on-site custom  classes at your place of employment.  E-Hazard can design a training program around your company’s unique electric safety program needs. We’ve designed specific training for several industries around the country and around the world including petrochemical, waste management, welding, automotive, communications, military, metals and much more.
Quick Links
Newsletter Archive


Dear ArcLetter Member,


The ArcWear™ Electric Arc and Safety Newsletter provides a quick update on Arc Rated and Flame Resistant Clothing issues and news from OSHA and standards committees. The newsletter is FREE, reaches over 14,000 people and will bring you up to date on the issues that surround flame resistant clothing for flash fire hazards and the electric arc. For previous newsletters or to sign up, visit or

Fines by OSHA on Electrical Hazards


Most citations include electrical hazards.


OSHA Logo  



View the citations and our commentary.  


Burn Up the Myth:  PPE Arc Ratings for Hi Vis and Rainwear

PPE:  Arc Ratings for Hi Vis and Rainwear


A customer at a utility had a question about wearing a Hi Vis vest or foul weather gear rated for HRC 1– minimum of 4 calories but up to 7.9 calories– when the arc flash assessment or company requirement is HRC 2, or minimum of 8 calories.


NFPA 70E – 2012 clearly states the clothing must meet or exceed the hazard to which the employee may be exposed.  The company’s own requirement for arc rated clothing with a minimum rating of 8 calories (HRC 2) meets this requirement if it is matched to the hazard.  Most utility work is not covered by NFPA 70E but by NESC and OSHA 1910.269 but the principles are still the same.  Don’t contribute to injury (like wearing a melting rainsuit that doesn’t meet the standards.  I agree that, if a worker is wearing daily wear of a shirt and pants, or coveralls, that meet NFPA 70E HRC 2 and then adds a HRC 1 vest, this could be considered added protection, as long as that vest is arc rated and meets ASTM F1506.  You would still have that daily wear layer of the shirt and pants with HRC 2 protection.


The 2004 version of NFPA 70E originally allowed for layering of clothing to meet the adequate calorie rating, but this changed in the 2009 revision due to the inability to enforce under-layer clothing materials and the fact that under layers could at some point ignite causing greater energy.  Who would they get to be the underwear police?  Additionally some two layer systems are better than others.  We have some 8 cal + 8 cal systems which only give 8 cal protection (even with two layers because of how the materials react in the arc.


In order to ensure the employee was wearing arc-rated clothing sufficient for their hazard exposure, NFPA 70E changed the rule to match PPE to the hazard.  It is still “best practice” to wear layers of arc-rated clothing so no combustion takes place at all. 


I have spoken to many utilities and most require the Hi Vis vests and foul weather gear to be arc rated. At this time these arc-rated apparel are not readily available in HRC 2, 3 or 4.  Most high visibility rainwear products (meeting ANSI 107 and ASTM F1506) have an arc rating 4 to 7.9 calories; I personally have a Hi Vis vest and raingear with just under an 8 calorie rating. 


The ASTM F1891-06 Standard Specification for Arc and Flame Resistant Rainwear establishes applicable test methods, minimum physical  and thermal performance criteria, a suggested sizing guide, and suggested purchasing information for rainwear for use by workers who may be exposed to thermal hazards of momentary electric arcs and open flames.  It also requires that the material response characteristics for rainwear material, including afterflame time, breakopen, charring, dripping, electric arc ignition, embrittlement, melting, and shrinkage, shall be reported for two typical exposures at least equal to the arc rating and also for two typical exposures at least two times the arc rating.


There is an exception to the above answer, however, in the  NESC ®(National Electrical Safety Code) 2012.  Under Section 41, General requirements, it states that employers must assess potential exposure to an electric arc for employees working on or near energized lines, parts, and equipment.  If the assessment determines that a potential exposure greater than 2 cal/cm2 exists, the employer then must perform a detailed arc hazard analysis to determine the effective arc rating of clothing to be worn.  The code requires employees “to wear clothing or a clothing system with an effective arc rating not less than the anticipated level of arc energy.”


The EXCEPTION to this is:  If the clothing or clothing system required by this rule has the potential to create additional or greater hazards than the possible exposure to the heat energy of the electric arc, then clothing or a clothing system with an effective arc rating less than that required by this rule may be worn. 


Several notes follow this exception.  Note 1:  Assessments performed to determine potential exposure to an electric arc consider the affected employee’s assigned tasks and/or work activities.  Note 2:  A clothing system (multiple layers) that includes an outer layer of flame resistant material and an inner layer of non-flame resistant natural fiber material has been shown to block more heat than a single layer.  The effect of the combination of these multiple layers may be referred to as the effective arc rating (e.g., EBT, ATPV).  Note 3:  Engineering controls can be utilized to reduce arc energy levels and work practices can be utilized to reduce exposure levels.  Rainwear wouldn’t meet this exception. It is normally used for conductive clothing for HV work which may not meet the arc flash protection values but has another purpose to prevent shock.  –  Pat Stagno 

Pat Stagno





NFPA 70E Errata No:  70E-12-1

NFPA 70E® 
Standard for Electrical Safety in the Workplace® 
2012 Edition

Reference: Various
Errata No.: 70E-12-1

The National Electrical Code Correlating Committee notes the following in the 2012 edition of NFPA 70E®, Standard for Electrical
Safety in the Workplace®. 
1. General Throughout the document: Wherever Annex B through Annex P have been referenced, add the word “Informative” before the word “Annex”. Revise all references to “Informative Annex A” to “Annex A.”

2. Page 70E-24 Table 130.4(C)(a): Revise 0.1 m in row 7, column 5 to 0.7 m

3. Page 70E-37 Note 3 to Table 130.7(C)(15)(a): Revise 130.8(C)(7) and 130.8(D) to 130.7(C)(7)(a) and 130.7(D)(1) respectively

4. Page 70E-37 Note 5 to Table 130.7(C)(15)(a): Revise the fifth sentence to read – Working distance was 18 in. (455 mm)

5. Page 70E-38 Note b to Table 130.7(C)(15)(b): Revise by deleting the phrase at the end of the note – “, and the rubber gloves chosen are required to be arc rated to the potential exposure level of the hazard/risk category”

6. Page 70E-40 Table 130.7(C)(16), Note 1: Revise Table 130.7(C)(9) to Table 130.7(C)(15)(a) and Table 130.7(C)(15)(b)

7. Page 70E-41 Title of 130.8: Delete “Uninsulated”

8. Page 70E-52 320.3(C)(3)(c): Revise 110.7(F) to 110.3(F)

9. Page 70E-62 C.2.1.2 Column 2: Revise “plus 102 mm (4.0 in.)” to read “plus 100 mm (4.0 in.)”

10. Page 70E-63 Table D.1: Delete row D.8 in its entirety

11. Page 70E-85 Table H.3(b), Category – Greater than 12 cal/cm2, , Other personal protective equipment, fifth row: Delete the words “Arc-rated gloves or” and capitalize the word “Rubber”

12. Page 70E-98 Informative Annex P: Revise OSHA 18001 to OHSAS 18001 

ArcWear™ Arc Testing Dates

ArcWear™ Testing
 Nov 26-30
Dec 10-14
Jan 14-18
Feb. 18-23


ASTM F1959, ASTM F2178, ASTM F887 fall protection arc testing and mannequin testing are scheduled at the Kinectrics Lab in Toronto on the dates above.   

Ship materials or clothing to:   
Hugh Hoagland
13113 Eastpoint Park Blvd.
Suite E
Louisville, KY
PH: 502-333-0510   
We must receive materials or clothing one week before the test date for sample preparation, or make arrangements to ship to the lab in Canada. New and non US/Canadian Customers must make payment before test date.  Testing is offered on a first come/first served basis with priority for consulting customers. 
  • $100 per material for prep/washing and cutting panels; ($200 for items arriving less than 7 days before test date to cover preparation overtime)
  • $200 for shipping a signed hard-copy report internationally

No guarantee is made of when testing will occur; we do all in our power to test within one month of receipt.  


All testing is performed at Kinectrics High Current lab in Toronto, Canada.  Kinectrics is an ISO 17025 accredited lab by the Standards Council of Canada.
View our Arc Test Data.
Get details on past Arc Flash Articles.

ASTM Standards Tracker Alert #1
ASTM International Logo

Newly approved is ASTM D1048 – 12 Standard Specification for Rubber Insulating Blankets.  


This specification covers the acceptance testing of insulating rubber blankets that are used for the personal protection of workers from accidental contact with live electrical conductors, apparatus, or circuits. 


Two types of blankets, differing in chemical and physical characteristics, are provided and are designated as: Type I, made from properly vulcanized high-grade cis-1,4-polyisoprene rubber compound of natural or synthetic origin that is non-resistant to ozone; and Type II, made of any elastomer or combination of elastomeric compounds that is resistant to ozone. Five classes of blankets, designated as Classes 0, 1, 2, 3, and 4, are assigned according to electrical protection characteristics. Styles of blankets are designated in accordance to construction characteristics, namely: Style A, blankets free of any reinforcements; and Style B, blankets incorporated with reinforcement(s). When evaluated in accordance with the test procedures detailed herein, the blankets shall adhere to the following property requirements: electrical properties such as phase-phase maximum use voltage, AC and DC proof-test voltages, AC and DC dielectric breakdown test voltages, and AC and DC clearances; and physical and chemical properties such as ozone resistance, moisture absorption, tensile strength, tension set, elongation, drape stiffness, flex stiffness, tear resistance, resistance to accelerated heat aging, and puncture resistance.


ASTM Standards Tracking Alert #2
ASTM International Logo New copies of the following ASTM Standards and Work Items descriptions are now available.
Just click on any new standard to view the document summary page and purchase the standard from ASTM.
New approved ASTM Standards:

F1958/F1958M – Standard Test Method for Determining the Ignitability of Non-flame-Resistant Materials for Clothing by Electric Arc Exposure Method Using Mannequins has been revised to F1958/F1958M-12 developed by Committee F18.65, ASTM BOS Volume 10.03.


F1959/F1959M – Standard Test Method for Determining the Arc Rating of Materials for Clothing has been revised to F1959/F1959M-12 developed by Committee F18.65, ASTM BOS Volume 10.03.


F2178 – Standard Test Method for Determining the Arc Rating and Standard Specification for Eye or Face Protective Products has been revised to F2178-12 developed by Committee F18.65, ASTM BOS Volume 10.03.


F2522 – Standard Test Method for Determining the Protective Performance of a Shield Attached on Live Line Tools or on Racking Rods for Electric Arc Hazards has been revised to F2522-12 developed by Committee F18.35, ASTM BOS Volume 10.03.


F2621 – Standard Practice for Determining Response Characteristics and Design Integrity of Arc Rated Finished Products in an Electric Arc Exposure has been revised to F2621-12 developed by Committee F18.65, ASTM BOS Volume 10.03.

 New ASTM Work Items:
WK39570 – Standard Terminology Relating to Care Labeling for Apparel, Textile, Home Furnishing, and Leather Products is a work item revision to existing standard D3136-04(2008)e1 

ESW 2013 Registration Open 

Dates are March 11-15, 2013, in Dallas, TX.

The IEEE IAS Electrical Safety Workshop provides a forum to enable and accelerate change in the electrical safety culture and push the envelope on what is possible in preventing workplace injuries from electrical hazards.


The IEEE IAS Electrical Safety Workshop mission is more about path finding and creating the future in electrical safety by changing how we think about what is possible, or in other words, changing the electrical safety culture. 

Race for the Cure

In order to raise funds for breast cancer awareness, ArcWear/e-Hazard staff, friends and family took part in the 5k Susan G. Komen Race for the Cure on October 13 in Louisville.

Komen Walk 10-13-12  

Electrical Safety News


Shocked and burned: Workers get nasty shock in Australia
11-30-2012 15:25:41 PM

Several maintenance workers from SP Ausnet in Wodonga were changing a transformer & came into contact with high-voltage power lines, suffering severe electric shock. Find out more from the BorderMail webpage dated 10/24/12.…»

Boston College Employee Taken to Hospital Following Electric Shock
11-30-2012 15:22:19 PM

A Boston College electrician was shocked while performing work at Lyons Hall in Newton;  the injuries were non-life-threatening. Getting into the habit of wearing rubber insulating gloves when doing all electrical work prevents almost all these incidents.  What if we had low voltage gloves that were more comfortable, thinner and less costly?  Would workers wear […]…»

Rutherford, NJ, police officers revive utility worker
11-30-2012 15:21:59 PM

An unidentified PSE&G lineman, working on a pole damaged from Hurricane Sandy, came into contact with an energized 13,000v line and suffered severe electrical shock.    Three police officers were able to revive the unresponsive utility worker;  his condition and name remain unknown. Find out more from NorthJersey.Com webpage dated 11/5/12.…»

Man electrocuted at Marks and Spencer in Tunbridge Wells
11-30-2012 15:20:58 PM

A contractor working in an area not open to the public suffered a fatal shock at the Marks and Spencer store in the Royal Victoria Shopping Centre in Tunbridge Wells, England.  Many workers are affected by electricity.  Some level of electrical safety training should be done with all workers. Read the details from This is […]…»

Worker in India killed in explosion days before 50th birthday
11-30-2012 15:19:51 PM

An employee in Siparia, India, was killed at a bitumen plant that was purchased 2 months previous at an auction.  Doodnath Bhimull was wiring up the cables and checking to see that all the motors from the plant were running.  Testing was done the day before, and he came back today to verify that everything was […]…»

Article by Reza Tajali/Schneider Electric: Six Steps Can Reduce Arc Flash Hazard And Protect Workers And Equipment
11-30-2012 15:19:11 PM

Read the  article dated 10/30/12, written by Reza Tajali of Schneider Electric, that appeared in this month’s Plant Engineering magazine: “There are five important steps that companies should take to reduce the occurrence of electrical accidents and better protect workers and employers from the physical, financial, and statutory consequences of electrical accidents. These steps are required […]…»

11-30-2012 15:18:51 PM

Big Tex, the 52 foot cowboy overlooking the Texas State Fair for 60 years, burnt to a crips when an electrical short started a fire in his right boot. Dickies has FR.  Tex must not have done a hazard assessment! Was this an electrical fire also known as an electric arc?  This is what electric arcs […]…»

OSHA cites History Construction Management for exposing workers to lead, other hazards at Odell, Ill., plant
11-30-2012 15:18:09 PM

History Construction Management LLC of Odell, IL, was cited $59.2k by OSHA for alleged serious violations including using flexible electrical cords as a substitute for fixed wiring and improperly altering electrical cords. Find out more from OSHA’s News Release dated 11/1/12.  …»

Craft brewer cited by US Labor Department’s OSHA for safety hazards at New Hampshire brewery following fatality caused by April keg explosion
11-30-2012 15:15:36 PM

Oregon-based Craft Brew Alliance Inc. was cited $63.5k by OSHA at its Redhook Brewery in Portsmouth, NH, for workplace safety violations following the explosion & subsequent death of an employee using compressed air to purge liquid from the interior of a plastic keg.   Unrelated to the explosion were serious violations including incomplete procedures for locking […]…»

Cleaner’s out-of-body experience after electric shock from industrial cables
11-30-2012 15:15:14 PM

John Scrimshaw was cleaning paint splashes from cables  at Hamworthy Combustion Engineering Ltd of Poole, England, when he suffered a shock & was thrown 5 metres to the ground.  The Health and Safety Executive found the cables, which powered an overhead crane used to move heavy industrial heating units, were bare and had not been […]…»


Train the Trainer Class

E-Hazard offers ‘Train the Trainer‘ courses several times per year.  This 3-or-4 day intensive training program is designed to prepare qualified trainers to deliver instruction to others based on NFPA 70E and OSHA requirements. e-Hazard started this training to “raise the bar” in the electrical industry.  Most of the safety training companies require you to hire their trainers.  We offer this but we also provide training materials and trainer “training” and coaching so you can develop in-house expertise without “breaking the bank”. See what over 400 other trainers are saying about the e-Hazard TTT class and our materials.


  Upcoming TTT classes:

February 18th – February 21st, 2013 — Seattle, WA

March 4th – March 7th, 2013 — Louisville, KY




  Fuse used


Surprise Visitors

 Random visitors to our offices!

Deer  Birds

Arc Flash Training Forum
Join our Arc Flash Training Forum for online discussions regarding arc flash and electrical safety, arc flash studies, standards and code, and much more.
Arc Flash Forum  
Our newsletter is sponsored by many companies around the world.  If you have ideas for articles or have questions, don’t hesitate to write.



Hugh Hoagland

13113 Eastpoint Park Blvd. Suite E
Louisville, KY 40223
Office: 502-333-0510

This email was sent to by | | 13113 Eastpoint Park Blvd. | STE E | Louisville | KY | 40223

Hugh Hoagland
About author:
Hugh Hoagland is the foremost tester of clothing and PPE exposed to electrical arcs and is an arc flash expert. Read more about Hugh.

Leave a Reply